ETX lawyer reacts to Supreme Court affirmative action ruling - KTRE.com | Lufkin and Nacogdoches, Texas

ETX lawyer reacts to Supreme Court affirmative action ruling

TYLER, TX (KLTV) -

In a 7-to-1 decision Monday, the Supreme Court side-stepped a sweeping decision on the use of race-conscious school admission policies.

In Fisher v. The University of Texas at Austin et. al, the justices were looking at the criteria at the University of Texas and whether it violates the equal protection rights of some white applicants. In a decision that surprised many Monday, the Court threw the case back to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals for further review.

Since the fall of 2004, UT has used race as one factor when admitting students outside of the statewide top ten percent rule.

But a white female student, Abby Fisher, says race is what kept her from being admitted to UT in 2008.

It's not known yet what effect the decision will have on affirmative action on college campuses.

"The law of the land of affirmative action is really unsettled right now," said Leigh Porter, a shareholder at the Wilson Law Firm in Tyler. "I think colleges are probably left kind of scratching their heads wondering what are we going to do? But really, right now, nothing's changed."

The last time the Supreme Court had dealt with affirmative action on college campuses was ten years ago, when they said that race can be one of many factors used to create a diverse student body as long as quotas aren't used. When they made that decision, though, the Court said colleges needed to use strict scrutiny to narrowly tailor their admissions plans so that they achieved diversity without putting too much weight on a student's race.

the Supreme Court said that the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals did not dig deeply enough into UT's admissions policy when it ruled in its favor and the University didn't adequately prove that the top ten percent admissions program doesn't create enough campus diversity.

"Basically what the Supreme Court is saying by saying strict scrutiny is, no, you have to dig in there," Porter said. "You have to see, I mean, was there - you can't just assume, or presume, that what they're telling you is correct. You need to look and see, was there another race-neutral alternative they could have used."

It's not clear when the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals will take this case up, but Porter says it's very possible the Supreme Court will see this case again in a year or two.

Copyright 2013 KLTV. All rights reserved.

  • East Texas NewsMore>>

  • Developing: Lufkin Police confirmed shots fired in Crown Colony

    Developing: Lufkin Police confirmed shots fired in Crown Colony

    Sunday, November 19 2017 4:53 PM EST2017-11-19 21:53:47 GMT

    Lufkin PD spokeswoman, Jessica Pebsworth, has stated that a person is barricaded inside of a home. 

    More >>

    Lufkin PD spokeswoman, Jessica Pebsworth, has stated that a person is barricaded inside of a home. 

    More >>
  • Drivers have been identified in two-car accident near Angelina- Polk county line

    Drivers have been identified in two-car accident near Angelina- Polk county line

    Sunday, November 19 2017 2:52 PM EST2017-11-19 19:52:26 GMT
    Source: KTRE StaffSource: KTRE Staff

    The drivers involved in two-car accident earlier this week on U.S. 59 near Clark’s Ferry road have been identified. 

    More >>

    The drivers involved in two-car accident earlier this week on U.S. 59 near Clark’s Ferry road have been identified. 

    More >>
  • Lufkin's Community Food Drive built on woman's legacy

    Lufkin's Community Food Drive built on woman's legacy

    Saturday, November 18 2017 9:28 PM EST2017-11-19 02:28:07 GMT
    Source: KTRE StaffSource: KTRE Staff
    The Community Food Drive in Lufkin is special to some because of the large amount of people it brings together from all walks of life.  "It's just like so many different people, very diverse," said volunteer, Priscilla Gonzalez. "It's just kind of cool to see all these people coming together to do one thing." For others, like Keith Kennedy, it's all about the service being provided to the greater community. "They're in miracle territory,...More >>
    The Community Food Drive in Lufkin is special to some because of the large amount of people it brings together from all walks of life.  "It's just like so many different people, very diverse," said volunteer, Priscilla Gonzalez. "It's just kind of cool to see all these people coming together to do one thing." For others, like Keith Kennedy, it's all about the service being provided to the greater community. "They're in miracle territory,...More >>
Powered by Frankly