Settlement reached in West Sabine Elementary defecation check la - KTRE.com | Lufkin and Nacogdoches, Texas

Settlement reached in West Sabine Elementary defecation check lawsuit

LUFKIN, TX (KTRE) -

Both sides in a federal lawsuit against the three West Sabine Independent School District employees have reached an agreement.

The original complaint included the school district in the lawsuit but the plaintiff and his attorney made  the decision to drop West Sabine ISD from the lawsuit after it was determined that there was no evidence that the school board, which is the policy maker for the district, knew anything about the search beforehand.

In the lawsuit, the parent of a fourth-grader alleged that faculty members violated his son's Fourth Amendment rights when they checked his rear end for evidence of feces.

"The Court has been advised through the Report of Mediation that the parties have settled all claims in controversy in the above reference case," stated an order filed in the U.S. District Court's Marshall Division. "The final motion to dismiss should be submitted on or before 30 days from the date of this order."

Wes Little and his Lufkin attorney, Brent Watkins, filed the federal lawsuit against West Sabine ISD, principal Deborah Lane, and school nurse Jo Ann Clark back in February 2013.

"My thought was that the school had taken this too far," Watkins said in a previous East Texas News story.

Little filed the lawsuit two weeks after Lane and Clark checked every fourth-grader for evidence to find out who had defecated on the gym floor. School staff said they only peeked inside their pants. However, the lawsuit alleged that Clark pulled each child's pants and underwear down past their buttocks.

"In this case even if they had, which they didn't find any feces I don't know that would've been proof they were looking for," Watkins said in a previous East Texas News story. "I don't know that would have given sufficient proof to say that this child is the child that was defecating on the gym floor."

Watkins said, "You have to have specific evidence against those people or at least a suspicion to be able to search those individuals and in this case we didn't feel, my client didn't feel, there was sufficient evidence to do a search of that nature."

In the complaint, Little argued his son's Fourth Amendment rights were violated because of the "supposed school infraction and the limited likelihood of injury to the student populace."

The Fourth Amendment guards against unreasonable searches and seizures.

Watkins says he and his client are happy with the outcome of the case.

"The purpose of this suit was not to make money," said Watkins. "The purpose of this suit was to bring attention to something my client felt was improper and hopefully bring attention to in a way that would correct it for the future and I think that has been done."

Copyright 2014 KTRE. All rights reserved.

  • East Texas NewsMore>>

  • Community rallying behind Lufkin all-stars

    Community rallying behind Lufkin all-stars

    Sunday, August 19 2018 8:23 PM EDT2018-08-20 00:23:07 GMT
    Photo: KTREPhoto: KTRE

    Making history, once again, fans, friends and family members of the Lufkin Little League Junior League team cheered behind the all stars on Sunday at Buffalo Wild Wings.

    More >>

    Making history, once again, fans, friends and family members of the Lufkin Little League Junior League team cheered behind the all stars on Sunday at Buffalo Wild Wings.

    More >>
  • Chinese Taipei squeaks by Lufkin 2-0 in JLWS

    Chinese Taipei squeaks by Lufkin 2-0 in JLWS

    Sunday, August 19 2018 2:18 PM EDT2018-08-19 18:18:34 GMT
    JLWSJLWS

    The All-Stars from the Pineywoods battled Chinese Taipei less than 24 hours after beating California in the U.S. Championship game. Chinese Taipei entered the game after run-ruling Mexico in the International Championship. In the first inning of the heavyweight showdown both teams got a runner on base but both teams left the runner stranded. Lufkin's Christian Mum...

    More >>

    The All-Stars from the Pineywoods battled Chinese Taipei less than 24 hours after beating California in the U.S. Championship game. Chinese Taipei entered the game after run-ruling Mexico in the International Championship. In the first inning of the heavyweight showdown both teams got a runner on base but both teams left the runner stranded. Lufkin's Christian Mum...

    More >>
  • Lufkin Wins! All-Stars beat California 5-2 to advance to World Championship at JLWS

    Lufkin Wins! All-Stars beat California 5-2 to advance to World Championship at JLWS

    Saturday, August 18 2018 8:49 PM EDT2018-08-19 00:49:38 GMT

    Lufkin was hoping to bring home a second straight U.S. Championship with Little League baseball, this time at the Junior League World Series. The U.S. Championship was a rematch of a game a few days earlier against California. The first game saw Lufkin win 2-0 on a complete game shutout by Mark Requena. Lufkin would end up being the away team in the title game. It didn't take long for the scoring to start for Lufkin with clean up hitter Sam Flores got the scoring started early for L...

    More >>

    Lufkin was hoping to bring home a second straight U.S. Championship with Little League baseball, this time at the Junior League World Series. The U.S. Championship was a rematch of a game a few days earlier against California. The first game saw Lufkin win 2-0 on a complete game shutout by Mark Requena. Lufkin would end up being the away team in the title game. It didn't take long for the scoring to start for Lufkin with clean up hitter Sam Flores got the scoring started early for L...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly